St. John's College
St. John's College
  • 541
  • 638 089
Watch Joanna Thornhill (SF24) Converse in Fluent Latin
Thornhill, who can speak, write, and read ancient Greek and Latin, chats with OPPD Director Charles Bergman about the importance of learning ancient languages.
Переглядів: 1 183

Відео

Steven Crowell: The Challenge of Heidegger's Approach to Technology
Переглядів 37814 днів тому
Of all the writings Heidegger published after Being and Time, "The Question Concerning Technology" (1950) is surely the most widely taught and discussed. It is not hard to understand why. Since 1950, our dependence on technical devices, and the environmental consequences of tech- nological manipulation of nature, have only become more oppressive, and Heidegger's essay provides an intuitively po...
The Erik S. Kristensen Memorial Lecture by Roger Carstens 2024
Переглядів 20814 днів тому
The annual Erik S. Kristensen Memorial Lecture, Wednesday, April 3rd in the Great Hall. This lecture series is jointly sponsored by the U.S. Naval Academy and St. John’s College with funding from the Navy Seals Foundation. Lieutenant Commander Kristensen was a graduate of the Academy and our GI (AGI00). While serving as a Navy Seal he was killed on a search and rescue mission in Afghanistan in ...
The Legacy of Francis Scott Key
Переглядів 16121 день тому
This panel event, organized by the St. John's College History Task Force, will discuss the complicated legacy of Francis Scott Key, one of the college's most notable alumni. Questions for the panelists may be submitted in advance or during the panel to chtf@sjc.edu. PANELISTS: PROF. MARK CLAGUE | author of the 2022 cultural biography of the Star-Spangled Banner, O Say Can You Hear? MARC LEEPSON...
Dean's Lecture Series: Thornton C. Lockwood
Переглядів 8221 день тому
On the evening of Friday, March 22, 2024, Thornton C. Lockwood, Professor of philosophy at Quinnipiac University, delivers his lecture “On Aristotle's Politics: Nature, justice, and constitutions.” Several senses of the term "nature" feature prominently in the first book of Aristotle's Politics, although the term is generally absent from the rest of the Politics; justice and the notion of "cons...
Llyd Wells- Clima(c)tic Change: Twenty Million Hands and the Living Wavering Globe
Переглядів 18221 день тому
DEAN'S LECTURE SERIES Climatic change demands of us climactic change. We have yet fully to admit it. Perhaps we never shall. Can we be serious about climate change? How? That's the core of this lecture, which will try to be serious scientifically, philosophically and literarily.
Pierre-Julien Harter: Buddhist metaphysics?
Переглядів 445Місяць тому
DEAN'S LECTURE SERIES: 2024 ANNUAL ROHRBACH LECTURE "Buddhist metaphysics? Making the case for enlarging metaphysics with Madhyamika philosophy, or, how emptiness is relevant to what there is" Thumbnail image art: Nagarjuna with Thirty of the Eighty-four Mahasiddhas, 1700 - 1799, Rubin Museum of Art Buddhist metaphysics, especially in the Madhyamika version which insists on the emptiness of all...
St John's College Great Conversations - Bob Woodward and Governor Wes Moore
Переглядів 230Місяць тому
On Octorober 29th, 2023, nearly 500 people gathered in the Francis Scott Key Auditorium at St. John's College to hear Bob Woodward and Governor Wes Moore speak as part of the Great Conversations series, presented by the Friends Board of St. John’s College and sponsored by PNC Bank. For a list of lectures, please visit the Formal Lecture Series page on our website www.sjc.edu/annapolis/events/le...
Tutor Panel on Shakespeare: "A Monument without a Tomb"
Переглядів 341Місяць тому
DEAN'S LECTURE SERIES "A Monument without a Tomb:" St. John's Celebrates Major Scenes from Shakespeare's First Folio TUTOR PANEL: Alison Chapman, Charlie Barrett, Krishnan Venkatesh, & Jay Smith In his Preface to the First Folio (1623), Shakespeare's friend and fellow author Ben Jonson described the bard as a "monument without a tomb," attempting to capture Shakespeare's enduring vitality as bo...
Frank Pagano: "Modernity for Fools and Knaves: Machiavelli's Mandragola and Shakespeare's All's...
Переглядів 518Місяць тому
"Modernity for Fools and Knaves: Machiavelli's Mandragola and Shakespeare's All's Well That Ends Well" (This lecture is part of the Carol J. Worrell Annual Series on Literature.) DEAN'S LECTURE SERIES: In chapter 15 of The Prince Machiavelli famously recommends "going to the effectual truth of the thing rather than to the imagination of it." If political writers wish to be effective, then they ...
Dean's Lecture Series: Dan Harrell
Переглядів 137Місяць тому
February 23, 2024, Annapolis tutor, Dan Harrell, deliver his lecture, "Being a Book". He offers this description: "When the so-called New Program was established at St. John’s College in 1937, conversation was to play no essential role-at least if you believe the first statement of the program, written by Scott Buchanan. Where you would expect the word “conversation” you find “instruction” inst...
"Philosophy as an Aid to Invention and Creativity" by David Shafer
Переглядів 144Місяць тому
DEAN'S LECTURE SERIES: We welcome David Shafer, who has designed hi-tech optical systems for the last 57 years, for astronomy, medicine, space surveillance, laser fusion, cinematography cameras, top secret military projects, and the manufacture of state-of-the-art computer chips. One of his unusual telescope designs went to Saturn while another landed on a comet. He designed a novel stereo view...
Dean's Lecture Series: Leah Lasell
Переглядів 240Місяць тому
Leah Lasell, Annapolis tutor, delivers the National Endowment for the Humanities lecture “On Motion” this, Friday, February 24, 2023, in the Great Hall. The new science of motion presented in the last two days of The Two New Sciences is Galileo's last word in a lifelong argument with Aristotle. Galileo lets us hear echoes of this argument by including the Aristotelian, Simplicio, among his char...
"Ecology, Evolution, and Ontology of Elevational Ranges" by Ethan Linck
Переглядів 3092 місяці тому
"Ecology, Evolution, and Ontology of Elevational Ranges" by Ethan Linck
What is the Measure of Electricity? by Howard Fisher
Переглядів 2722 місяці тому
What is the Measure of Electricity? by Howard Fisher
Dean's Lecture Series: Carl "Trip" Young
Переглядів 1142 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Carl "Trip" Young
Dean's Lecture Series: Jacob Howland
Переглядів 1932 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Jacob Howland
Dean's Lecture Series: Pater Edmund Waldstein
Переглядів 3252 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Pater Edmund Waldstein
The Andrew Steiner Memorial Lecture: Alexandra Horowitz
Переглядів 1022 місяці тому
The Andrew Steiner Memorial Lecture: Alexandra Horowitz
Dean's Lecture Series: Patricia Locke On Becoming Human in The Tale of Genji
Переглядів 2122 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Patricia Locke On Becoming Human in The Tale of Genji
Dean's Lecture Series: Jacques Duvoisin on Aristotle’s Hypothetical Method in De Anima
Переглядів 2282 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Jacques Duvoisin on Aristotle’s Hypothetical Method in De Anima
Croquet 40th Promo
Переглядів 2,5 тис.3 місяці тому
Croquet 40th Promo
Dean's Lecture Series: Enrique Galvez
Переглядів 1563 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Enrique Galvez
Dean's Lecture Series: Rebecca Goldner
Переглядів 1403 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Rebecca Goldner
Dean's Lecture Series: Fred Moten on Plato, Dickinson, and the Philosophical Blues
Переглядів 2 тис.3 місяці тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Fred Moten on Plato, Dickinson, and the Philosophical Blues
Spring 2024 Annapolis Graduate Institute Convocation
Переглядів 1684 місяці тому
Spring 2024 Annapolis Graduate Institute Convocation
Dean's Lecture Series: Kevin Kambo
Переглядів 4595 місяців тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Kevin Kambo
Dean's Lecture Series: Ron Haflidson
Переглядів 3346 місяців тому
Dean's Lecture Series: Ron Haflidson
A Colloquy in Honor of Eva Brann: Peter Kalkavage and Eric Salem
Переглядів 6476 місяців тому
A Colloquy in Honor of Eva Brann: Peter Kalkavage and Eric Salem
A Colloquy in Honor of Eva Brann: Joan Silver and Janet Dougherty
Переглядів 3666 місяців тому
A Colloquy in Honor of Eva Brann: Joan Silver and Janet Dougherty

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @MisterandMrsPC
    @MisterandMrsPC 8 днів тому

    Eva Brann 2023年10月9日查看翻译30周johnniealumni 30周 查看翻译1次赞回复30周2次赞回复 查看翻译Un-Willing: An Inquiry into the Rise of Will s Power and an Attempt to Undo It Paperback - October 7, 2014 - #bradleyhand #fontofall...........±±±±iı±±±when did the silk cut jaguar win le mars#wellinvolved by Eva Brann (Author)napisala Eva Brann (autor) 5.0 5.0 od 5 zvjezdica 3 ocjene Pogledajte sve formate i izdanja Od davnina su filozofi pisali o "volji". Ali volja je više od filozofske i znanstvene teme. U našem svakodnevnom govoru, što mislimo kada govorimo o "volji"? Riječi volje pojavljuju se svugdje na engleskom jeziku. Mi stvaramo oporuke. Vršimo snagu volje. Ponekad smo svojeglavi, ali samo voljni prema drugima. Iznad svega, volja postoji stotinu puta dnevno, kada koristimo pomoćni glagol "volja" kako bismo izrazili svoje namjere ili očekivanja za budućnost, ili jednostavno ukazali na buduće vrijeme. Ipak, potreban je samo trenutak razmišljanja da bi se vidjelo da ovdje postoji ogroman raspon značenja, pa tako nešto o čemu treba razmišljati. Štoviše, svi smo se tu i tamo, vjerojatno i kao djeca i kao odrasli, pitali jesmo li doista slobodni i znači li biti slobodan moći raditi ono što želimo ili biti oslobođeni želja i želja ili nečeg sasvim drugog. To jest, svi smo se borili s pitanjem slobodne volje na naše neformalne, neznanstvene načine. Konačno, vjerojatno smo se svi zapitali govore li ljudi koji govore o volji i snazi volje o istoj stvari ili čak govore razumno. Sve su to neka pitanja koja Eva Brann stavlja u središte Nespremnog. Ona uzima cijeli niz pitanja o volji koja se podrazumijevaju u našem svakodnevnom životu i svakodnevnom razmišljanju, artikulira ih, pokazuje nam kako se s njima postupalo unutar filozofske tradicije i suvremene znanstvene misli, a zatim se sama hrva s njima. "Eva Brann ima istinsku sposobnost za felicitno izražavanje, a kroz njezinu prozu može se osjetiti prisutnost velikog i strpljivog učitelja." Dennis L. Sepper, Sveučilište u Dallasu, autorica knjige Understanding Imagination Eva Brann članica je višeg fakulteta na St. John's Collegeu u Annapolisu u Marylandu, gdje je predavala pedeset i sedam godina. Dobitnica je Nacionalne medalje za humanističke znanosti. Njezine druge knjige uključuju Logotipe Heraklita, Osjećaj naših osjećaja, Hommage Amerikancima, Otvorene tajne / Unutarnji izgledi, Glazba Republike i Homeric Moments (sve u izdanju Paul Dry/bar˙^¬UT¶• Books). ‹›fifl#¢‰¥∞#Œ†ËÈØÈÖťIËøiOI˚∆KLN˚∆∆fi9HKJ˙^¬UT¶•§%^¶§$&I§&^T®§%6%¢§%∞¥†®E†®FD˙©ƒțYTFyTFuGuYGuYGJþYĞJŇpŵ´´´´Ê®¥†j;KH…^J…J"¬KJæÔ¬÷¿Ò˜÷¬˚JÈ¥¬¥Ì˚¨ÊRÁÊ´TR̓˙ÎSÓƒ∂ÌFD~GJFÎ˙ÌFÓ©ÏHGJFKHGÐ|" (TM) 8{P”:ÆÚLÆÚÆ∏ÒÚÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÒÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÚÒØ‹Ò≥≤øª^¢#¶958omfi›fl‡flfi‹°·fl‡*67t6•∞§®°§¶ª‡•‚(ºº°--±(≠º‚·≠)(≠89º-ÏÌ̇·‚fl››‹‹™⁄‹„fiÌÔ∏-´∂ƒ√∫∆¥~∆£33¥t2-±hgffÏÏÏfFfrh ±¯˜ˆı◊ÇÙÛŸŸ```~ç[§·¨ª^¶*¶∞#&€¢£%¢#!vEW†®qfř£‰∑œ∂ß√®ð¬∂†DFÓˆE[TY©˙f˜RÁË≤∆‡¨¥¬‡ûyJ%^†®¥Q%$£E†∞!‹¢%¡#$fi±%±∞%±@5±@¢®∑´±§§Å€€#¢∞]}{{}|”{“|{}|_{ÆÚ÷…≥÷≤-º^ø…ŘxThere once was a #YOUNG fam fam from Lewisham [familam;theFamily;memmochoe,etc.] <morsecode"Inspector Morse" Cherubim & Seraphim (TV Episode 1992) IMDb Morse's niece commits suicide very unexpectedly, as does another teen. Morse learns about the Rave scene and tries to save a girlfriend of his niece who is .. (this isn’t out of Stephen king or john grisham) It was hell for a while But the mosque made them smile So they picked it up and took it along with them. #wheretheresawill{allen?}theresaway @hotmail.com [a.000cœ.gay] £blahblahblah #mongoloid #sacismdd #seeifyoucanspotTħįşŒne P.S.💢sssssszzzzzhahahahohoho∏-´∂ƒ√∫∆¥~∆,|Æ»ÚÚ{Æ¿+±›™‹4™›‹⁄›⁄™‹?ÔÂÎÊjRÊÂťťþřbņmźqø--------

  • @MisterandMrsPC
    @MisterandMrsPC 8 днів тому

    Will this be recorded? I’d love to hear! 1次赞回复 o  Eva Brann 2023年10月9日查看翻译30周johnniealumni 30周 查看翻译1次赞回复30周2次赞回复 查看翻译 ‹›fifl#¢‰¥∞#Œ†ËÈØÈÖťIËøiOI˚∆KLN˚∆∆fi9HKJ˙^¬UT¶•§%^¶§$&I§&^T§%6%¢§%∞¥†E†FD˙ƒțYTFyTFuGuYGuYGJþYĞJŇpŵ´´´´Ê¥†j;KH…^J…J"¬KJæÔ¬÷¿Ò˜÷¬˚JÈ¥¬¥Ì˚¨ÊRÁÊ´TR̓˙ÎSÓƒ∂ÌFD~GJFÎ˙ÌFÓÏHGJFKHGÐ|"{P”:ÆÚLÆÚÆ∏ÒÚÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÒÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÚÒØ‹Ò≥≤øª^¢#¶958omfi›fl‡flfi‹°·fl‡*67t6•∞§°§¶ª‡•‚(ºº°--±(≠º‚·≠)(≠89º-ÏÌ̇·‚fl››‹‹⁄‹„fiÌÔ∏-´∂ƒ√∫∆¥~∆£33¥t2-±hgffÏÏÏfFfrh ±¯˜ˆı◊ÇÙÛŸŸ```~ç[§·¨ª^¶*¶∞#&€¢£%¢#!vEW†qfř£‰∑œ∂ß√ð¬∂†DFÓˆE[TY˙f˜RÁË≤∆‡¨¥¬‡ûyJ%^†¥Q%$£E†∞!‹¢%¡#$fi±%±∞%±@5±@¢∑´±§§Å€€#¢∞]}{{}|”{“|{}|_{ÆÚ÷…≥÷≤-º^ø…Řx 🤘🏿

  • @peterboersema7348
    @peterboersema7348 15 днів тому

    11:11 Robert Post seems unaware that Michael Anton is a graduate of St. John's College!

  • @alexanderhanksx
    @alexanderhanksx 22 дні тому

    Crazy to spend that much time preaching about social justice before the lecture even began. Can't even bring myself to listen now...

  • @andrewrae8064
    @andrewrae8064 24 дні тому

    the whole meta-language of judgments/sentences being more fundamental than concepts/ individual words thing wow

  • @ianherries6350
    @ianherries6350 29 днів тому

    Daddy ! Daddy! When I grow -up I want to be a Socialist... You can't be both Son.

  • @dubbelkastrull
    @dubbelkastrull 29 днів тому

    3:28 bookmark

  • @geoffrey2512
    @geoffrey2512 Місяць тому

    'Promosm' 🎉

  • @augustusbuzby9349
    @augustusbuzby9349 Місяць тому

    Eva's final line: "Nothing feels more expectantly free then to be left dangling in perplexity." Beautiful

  • @debodatta7398
    @debodatta7398 2 місяці тому

    Amazing stuff

  • @Headington_Oxford
    @Headington_Oxford 2 місяці тому

    Wonderful!!

  • @b-a-boon
    @b-a-boon 2 місяці тому

    the baboon feel sure that this a powerful presentiation but am afraid I not understand much,,,was expecting message of Jesus revolution love and peace

  • @drewburgess3039
    @drewburgess3039 2 місяці тому

    Thank you. An example of nostalgia as a modern phenomenon might be the way museums acquired fragmented works of ancient culture. The recognition of the traditional forms of sculpture as works of importance, was transformed to a new aesthetic--that of the fragment. It might be that the fragment represented the possibility of the self. Perhaps the Romanticism of the 19th century moment harkened back to Petrarch, the incomplete self in search of the whole. I appreciate your excellent lecture, thank you again.

  • @jessepappas3702
    @jessepappas3702 2 місяці тому

    Unifying and edifying ❤ 🐝

  • @SnowWhiteSIGINT
    @SnowWhiteSIGINT 3 місяці тому

    getting closer fred 😊 23:44

  • @emmadanumoren-de6zy
    @emmadanumoren-de6zy 3 місяці тому

    This is so good 🤗🤗 I just hope am accepted so I can join this great college 😭😭😭😭

  • @MegaThunderKitten
    @MegaThunderKitten 3 місяці тому

    Stolen valor

  • @jenniferarnold-delgado3489
    @jenniferarnold-delgado3489 3 місяці тому

    Pretty is balance , beauty is balance in motion -- beauty leads us to the future . Beauty is temporally creative .

  • @scottdinsmore9445
    @scottdinsmore9445 3 місяці тому

    25:40 I am enjoying this on youtube (academic gossip) "You're a SOPHIST"

  • @ajtexas1100
    @ajtexas1100 5 місяців тому

    a dangerous zionist.

  • @vitactiva73
    @vitactiva73 5 місяців тому

    Thanks for such a good insights about "grand lie" and its relationship with Kallipolis. I enjoyed it very much. I wish to see the debate too. But if I were there, I would like to ask Leo Strauss's comment about "Republic" as comedy? I think Kambo's interpretation reading Republic as tragedy, also Apology contends with his reading?

  • @user-yi4fl7bt8v
    @user-yi4fl7bt8v 5 місяців тому

    Lecture starts at 4:35

  • @ReadWithTshepho
    @ReadWithTshepho 6 місяців тому

    St John's is the home of original texts.

  • @goodstuff8156
    @goodstuff8156 6 місяців тому

    Who won?

  • @ReadWithTshepho
    @ReadWithTshepho 6 місяців тому

    From STEM to STEAM

  • @ReadWithTshepho
    @ReadWithTshepho 6 місяців тому

    My dream college.

  • @MorganBallardWheeler
    @MorganBallardWheeler 6 місяців тому

    Thank you for posting this! I can't wait to watch!

    • @MisterandMrsPC
      @MisterandMrsPC 8 днів тому

      Will this be recorded? I’d love to hear! 1次赞回复 o  Eva Brann 2023年10月9日查看翻译30周johnniealumni 30周 查看翻译1次赞回复30周2次赞回复 查看翻译 ‹›fifl#¢‰¥∞#Œ†ËÈØÈÖťIËøiOI˚∆KLN˚∆∆fi9HKJ˙^¬UT¶•§%^¶§$&I§&^T®§%6%¢§%∞¥†®E†®FD˙©ƒțYTFyTFuGuYGuYGJþYĞJŇpŵ´´´´Ê®¥†j;KH…^J…J"¬KJæÔ¬÷¿Ò˜÷¬˚JÈ¥¬¥Ì˚¨ÊRÁÊ´TR̓˙ÎSÓƒ∂ÌFD~GJFÎ˙ÌFÓ©ÏHGJFKHGÐ|"{P”:ÆÚLÆÚÆ∏ÒÚÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÒÆ∏ÚÒÆ∏ÚÒØ‹Ò≥≤øª^¢#¶958omfi›fl‡flfi‹°·fl‡*67t6•∞§®°§¶ª‡•‚(ºº°--±(≠º‚·≠)(≠89º-ÏÌ̇·‚fl››‹‹™⁄‹„fiÌÔ∏-´∂ƒ√∫∆¥~∆£33¥t2-±hgffÏÏÏfFfrh ±¯˜ˆı◊ÇÙÛŸŸ```~ç[§·¨ª^¶*¶∞#&€¢£%¢#!vEW†®qfř£‰∑œ∂ß√®ð¬∂†DFÓˆE[TY©˙f˜RÁË≤∆‡¨¥¬‡ûyJ%^†®¥Q%$£E†∞!‹¢%¡#$fi±%±∞%±@5±@¢®∑´±§§Å€€#¢∞]}{{}|”{“|{}|_{ÆÚ÷…≥÷≤-º^ø…Řx 🤘🏿

  • @ReadWithTshepho
    @ReadWithTshepho 6 місяців тому

    Wowowowowowoowoowoowow!!!!!!!

  • @ReadWithTshepho
    @ReadWithTshepho 6 місяців тому

    My kind of heaven.

  • @seoexpertshohel
    @seoexpertshohel 6 місяців тому

  • @Rico-Suave_
    @Rico-Suave_ 7 місяців тому

    Great video, thank you very much , note to self(nts) watched all of it 15:47

  • @raystargazer7468
    @raystargazer7468 7 місяців тому

    "Horizontal societies' is a bs journalist made up word.

  • @nkemdirimarukwe
    @nkemdirimarukwe 7 місяців тому

    So beautiful!.

  • @kaboom9500
    @kaboom9500 7 місяців тому

    Benjamin needs a raise!

  • @natewatl9423
    @natewatl9423 7 місяців тому

    Why a thumbnail photo from Santa Fe for an Annapolis event? 🤔

    • @stjohnscollege
      @stjohnscollege 7 місяців тому

      It's just the default thumbnail for live streams since there's no content yet.

  • @rogerconnolly3688
    @rogerconnolly3688 7 місяців тому

    I am an architect but lived as an artist solely for about 15 years. I did not use the gallery system but sold very directly to the public through art and craft markets and retail outlets, it was. very commercial. I aspired to make beautiful art and found the direct correlation between what sold and whether I thought it was beautiful or not. It is not an absolute but generally we all share the common idea of beauty.

  • @VictorHageman
    @VictorHageman 7 місяців тому

    38:52 "He is also unwilling to truly admit or examine the source of his dissatisfaction, because it would call the eminence of historicity itself into question." I'm not sure I understand this.

  • @lesliecunliffe4450
    @lesliecunliffe4450 7 місяців тому

    Thank you for posting this lecture, which I've only just discovered. Scruton developed great insights into why modernity has not created a built environment worthy of its citizens. I agree with the judgment he expresses at the very end of the questions where he states that Wittgenstein would be in complete agreement with the views expressed in this talk.

  • @ArtPhotographerLindsay
    @ArtPhotographerLindsay 8 місяців тому

    14:47

  • @user-hz8lo3tq9z
    @user-hz8lo3tq9z 8 місяців тому

    congratulations!

  • @AnonymousTraveler-ze2vm
    @AnonymousTraveler-ze2vm 8 місяців тому

    These are the intolerant, hateful poisonous creatures that have hijacked fields of study like intolerant tyrants. They stifle free thought and facts. Their only defense against facts is demonization in order to escape debate. The future requires inevitable changes which you cannot prevent. You are the perfect epitome of a hateful person.

  • @EvanProdromou
    @EvanProdromou 9 місяців тому

    This is wonderful!

  • @applehuang239
    @applehuang239 9 місяців тому

    Thank you so much for uploading this content!

  • @brkelly8803
    @brkelly8803 9 місяців тому

    Promo'SM

  • @SMullen-iw3ds
    @SMullen-iw3ds 9 місяців тому

    I feel bad for Scruton. Almost all the questions displayed a complete lack of understanding of everything he addressed in his talk. Maybe I have an easier time understanding his points because I was immersed in the theory and practice of building and design from a young age. It seemed to me, however, like his language was clear and plain enough for laymen to grasp. You could see his frustration with most of the questions and his relief when a decent one was presented to him.

  • @nancywysemen7196
    @nancywysemen7196 10 місяців тому

    pretty cool.

  • @psychonaut689
    @psychonaut689 10 місяців тому

    The thing-in-itself can't both be compulsory and accidental; Hoffe points out that it functions as a regulatory concept, a bit like a keystone that holds the system together.

  • @beoutside6517
    @beoutside6517 10 місяців тому

    The potential for a masters of middle eastern classics offered at St. John's is exciting. What would the languages and reading list be?

  • @DaveWasley
    @DaveWasley 10 місяців тому

    I'm rereading the first critique and am on the TD. I've been wracking my mind the past few days trying to work out what Kant's saying. This has been the clearest, most helpful video I've seen so far, so thanks. It's spooky though, over the past few years, I've read the Phenomenology of Spirit, the Science of Logic, and the Encyclopaedia Logic (all Hegel). In the Encyclopaedia Logic, this is also summarized quite well...then you realize that the first three chapters of PoS are basically explaining this in a dialectical form, too. Oddly enough, Hegel is easier to read, at least in translation, than Kant, but the Shorter Logic definitely puts a finger on the scale. Anyways, I came to this after watching the Dan Robinson lecture on the TD trying to figure out how Kant deduces the categories from pure self-consciousness as the simple unity of sense representations, and I think I must've read the same 30 some-odd pages of the Transcendental Analytic maybe 10+ times in a row. I accompany all my representations, and am their simple unity, but I wasn't comprehending how that deduction allows me to unify an object from the diversity within the sensory manifold. This was the only thing that made it clear: I *can* always deduce myself (but don't, consciously at least), but that deduction of I am is conceptual, so our originary transcendental proto-concept is the concept of simple unity of self as the being all representation happens to. As concept, it must comply with the logical forms of judgement, and since, in a word, in contains (or is the very) said diversity in sense, said diversity in sense must also comply with logical forms of judgement.

  • @johnbarrymore5827
    @johnbarrymore5827 10 місяців тому

    First